In this article
Your son's khotna is coming, and two roads lie in front of you. One is the traditional way, done by a hajam, as many families have done for years. The other is a device method, done by a doctor. Which is better for your child? Here is a plain, fair comparison.
First, one thing. This is not a verdict on any person. Many children have been circumcised by traditional practitioners and are well. The real question is not the name of the method. The real question is who does it, with what tools, and what happens if something goes wrong.
#What is the difference between the two methods?
In the traditional method, the hajam usually cuts the foreskin with a blade or scissors. The way it is done depends a great deal on the person and his training.
In a device method, a doctor places a small, single-use device on the child. The device guides where the cut is made and presses the edges together. The doctor chooses the size to fit your child. This is the method Salamah Care offers.
A device does not do the work by itself. A careful, trained hand still matters in both methods.
#How do they compare?
| Question | Traditional method | Device method with a doctor |
|---|---|---|
| Who does it | A hajam. Training differs from person to person. | A doctor. |
| Tools | Blade or scissors. Ask whether they are new or sterilised. | A single-use device, opened fresh for each child. |
| Pain relief | Ask what is used. | A doctor plans pain relief for your child. |
| Bleeding | Can happen. Ask how it is stopped. | Can happen. A doctor is there to manage it. |
| If something goes wrong | Ask where you would be taken. | The doctor is already with your child. |
| Healing | Varies. | Varies. Follow the doctor's aftercare. |
Look at the last rows. In both methods, a little bleeding is the most common problem. The NHS says that most people who have complications have only minor ones, such as bleeding. So the question is not whether a problem can happen. The question is whether someone trained is there to deal with it.
#What do studies say?
Researchers have compared device methods with the older cutting methods. The results are mixed. Some small studies found that devices were quicker and caused less bleeding. Other studies found that healing took longer with some devices. The results also differ from one device to another.
So be careful with anyone who says one method is perfect. No method is. Each study looked at a particular device, a particular group and a particular hospital. Ask your doctor which device is used, and why.
#What should you ask, whichever method you choose?
These questions matter more than the method itself.
- Who will do the procedure, and what is his training?
- Are the tools new or sterilised for every child?
- What is used for pain relief?
- What happens if there is bleeding?
- Is a doctor available afterwards if you have a worry?
- What are the aftercare steps, in writing or said clearly?
If you do not get clear answers, that tells you something. A good practitioner is glad to be asked.
Also think about your child's health. If he was born early, has a bleeding problem in the family, or has a problem with his penis from birth, tell the doctor first. In such cases the procedure may need special care, or may not be right.
#Which method is right for your family?
Only you can decide, with a doctor's advice. Some families choose a device method because a doctor does it, with single-use equipment and with care afterwards. Others have a family tradition. Both families want the same thing: a safe khotna and a healthy child.
A simple test can help. Imagine the day itself. Your child is calm, or he is frightened, or he bleeds a little more than you expected. Who is standing next to him? What do they do? If you can answer that clearly for your choice, you have chosen well. If you cannot, ask more questions before the day comes.
If you choose a traditional practitioner, still ask the questions above. Still follow the aftercare. Still keep a doctor's number ready.
#What to do next
Salamah Care in Mohammadpur, Dhaka, offers device cosmetic circumcision (khotna) for children, done by a doctor. If you want to talk about the method, contact us or call 01327-808822. To prepare your child, read Preparing Your Child for Khotna. For care at home afterwards, read Circumcision Aftercare.
A good khotna is a calm one. Ask your questions early, and choose the person you trust.
Frequently asked questions
Is device circumcision safer than the traditional method?
No method is free of risk. Studies give mixed results. What matters most is a trained person, clean single-use or sterilised tools, pain relief and a doctor close by if bleeding or infection occurs.
Can a hajam do khotna safely?
Some do it carefully, but training differs from person to person. If you choose this way, ask about training, tools, pain relief and what happens if there is bleeding, and keep a doctor's number ready.
What is the most common problem after khotna?
Bleeding is the most common minor problem, according to the NHS. Call a doctor at once if it is more than a small spot, or if there is fever, pus or trouble passing urine.
At what age can my son have khotna?
It depends on your child's health and your doctor's advice. Talk to a doctor first, especially if he was born early or there is a bleeding problem in the family.
Sources & further reading
Medical disclaimer. This article is for general information and does not replace advice from a qualified doctor. If you have symptoms, pain or a health concern, please see a clinician. In an emergency call 999.
Need cosmetic circumcision (khotna) in Dhaka?
Talk to the Salamah Care team in Mohammadpur. We will listen, explain your options clearly and guide you to the right care.




